Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Browse

Pima Sheriff Clears Guthrie Family, Focuses on Unknown DNA Suspect in Case

Pima Sheriff Clears Guthrie Family, Focuses on Unknown DNA Suspect in Case
View gallery

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos formally cleared all members of the Guthrie family as possible suspects in the disappearance and suspected kidnapping of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, even as investigators continued to search for an unknown man captured on doorbell video and identified through DNA found at the scene. nbcnews +1 The announcement came Feb. 16 after weeks of intense public scrutiny and online speculation surrounding the high-profile case, which began when Guthrie vanished from her home outside Tucson in the early hours of Feb. 1. nbcnews +1

Guthrie, the mother of “TODAY” co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, was last seen around 9:48 p.m. on Jan. 31 when a family member dropped her at home; her relatives reported her missing the next day after they could not reach her. azpm Authorities have treated the case as an abduction, releasing video of a masked, armed man on her porch, collecting DNA from her house that did not match Guthrie or those close to her, and fielding tens of thousands of tips amid a $100,000 FBI reward. cnn +2

Why the Sheriff Cleared the Guthrie Family

In a sharply worded statement, Nanos said the “Guthrie family — to include all siblings and spouses — has been cleared as possible suspects,” adding that “to suggest otherwise is not only wrong, it is cruel. The Guthrie family are victims plain and simple.” nbcnews +1 The sheriff’s office stressed that relatives had been “nothing but cooperative and gracious,” and that clearing them was intended to counter persistent rumors fueled by social media and some media commentary implying family involvement. wlos +1

Investigators had, as is standard, scrutinized those closest to Guthrie early in the probe, comparing family DNA and interviewing relatives while executing search warrants at multiple properties. cnn +1 But officials said forensic testing found DNA inside Guthrie’s home from an unknown individual rather than anyone in her immediate circle, reinforcing the decision to rule out the family and redirect investigative focus. cnn +1

Focus Shifts to Unknown Suspect, Digital and DNA Trail

With the family officially eliminated as suspects, investigators have zeroed in on the unidentified man seen on Guthrie’s porch in the early hours of Feb. 1, captured in footage recovered from her doorbell camera. cnn +1 The FBI described him as a male about 5'9" to 5'10", of average build, wearing black gloves, a balaclava and a 25‑liter Ozark Trail backpack sold exclusively at Walmart, and apparently carrying a handgun. fox61 +1 Authorities later recovered a black glove about two miles from Guthrie’s home that appears visually consistent with those in the video; preliminary testing showed DNA from an unknown male, with the profile expected to be uploaded to the national CODIS database once quality checks are complete. cnn +1

The case has generated more than 30,000 tips and at least one arrest related not to the kidnapping itself but to a fraudulent ransom demand sent to media outlets, as investigators warned that hoaxes and rumor-driven speculation can drain resources. nbcnews +1 The investigation has also drawn criticism from some former law-enforcement officials, who pointed to early, uncontrolled access to Guthrie’s property and mixed messaging to the public as potential missteps as the search entered its third week with no suspect named. gephardtdaily

The Bigger Picture

The decision to publicly clear the Guthrie family underlined a growing tension in modern high-profile investigations, where viral speculation and true-crime commentary can collide with the slow, methodical work of forensic analysis and tip-triage. As authorities lean on video forensics, retail data and DNA databases to identify the masked man in the footage, they are also appealing directly to the public for credible information, with Savannah Guthrie urging in a recent video plea that “it is never too late to do the right thing” for whoever is holding her mother. nbcnews +1